Showing posts with label PASPA. Show all posts
Showing posts with label PASPA. Show all posts

Wednesday, March 26, 2014

New Legal Brief Supports New Jersey Sports Betting

The libertarian Cato Institute and the Pacific Legal Foundation have filed an amicus brief in support of New Jersey's appeal to the US Supreme Court over its desire to offer legal sports betting within the state.  This is an interesting development as this brief is being done by third parties, with no direct stake in the matter.

It is unknown how much weight this will bear on the case, but for a well-regarded think tank to step into a case like this must be welcomed by pro-sports betting interests.

The story on this development can be found here.

Wednesday, November 27, 2013

New Jersey Taking Sports Betting Fight to US Supreme Court

The Las Vegas Review-Journal reports that Governor Christie of New Jersey is not giving up on the fight to allow sports betting in New Jersey.  After the appeals court declined to rehear the case, this is the only option left for New Jersey.

I have provided my views on this several times, where I think New Jersey is in the right in this case.  Each state has the ability on their own to decide what kinds of gambling, if any, should exist within their states.

My view is that the Supreme Court will take up this case due to the controversy between federal and state powers, which is the kind of topic the Supreme Court was designed to handle.

Other posts on this topic can be found here, here, here and here.

Wednesday, September 18, 2013

Appeals Court Ruling Against New Jersey Shows Path To Sports Betting

The United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit yesterday ruled against New Jersey in its attempt to implement sports betting by a 2-1 decision.  The case is now clear for New Jersey to appeal to the US Supreme Court.  Although a defeat at this stage, New Jersey can actually see very good news.  For the first time, a judge did side with New Jersey and against the US and the sports leagues.  The dissenting judge put forward a very well reasoned dissent that picked apart the majority opinion and showed in detail how PASPA was unconstitutional.

New Jersey does have the option of asking for the full Third Circuit to hear the case.  The information I received is that it doesn't do much for New Jersey to do that.  The first thing is that the full court could side with the majority, which doesn't help.  The second thing is that the loser is going to go to the US Supreme Court anyway, so why not go there now and save time and money?  That appears to be the path New Jersey will take.

The opponents of sports betting will take this as a great victory - not so fast.  From the majority opinion, this sentiment I found interesting:
We are cognizant that certain questions related to this case—whether gambling on sporting events is harmful to the games’ integrity and whether states should be permitted to license and profit from the activity—engender strong views. But we are not asked to judge the wisdom of PASPA or of New Jersey’s law, or of the desirability of the activities they seek to regulate. We speak only to the legality of these measures as a matter of constitutional law. Although this “case is made difficult by [Appellants’] strong arguments” in support of New Jersey’s law as a policy matter, see Gonzales v. Raich, 545 U.S. 1, 9 (2005), our duty is to “say what the law is,” Marbury v. Madison, 1 Cranch 137, 177 (1803). “If two laws conflict with each other, the courts must decide on the operation of each.” Id. New Jersey’s sports wagering law conflicts with PASPA and, under our Constitution, must yield. We will affirm the District Court’s judgment.
So they pretty much put blinders on and crafted an affirming opinion based on a subset of the issues.  The court also just used the "rational basis" test and took only a cursory look at PASPA to find anything to say that PASPA was a regulation of interstate commerce, as opposed to Congress using a state as a puppet, which isn't allowed.  In other words, if Congress wanted to outlaw the sale of beef jerky, Congress can do that directly, but they cannot tell the states to pass laws to prohibit beef jerky or keep them from passing laws allowing beef jerky, while declining to do so themselves.  In the case of PASPA, they allow some states to have sports betting, but not others, which is even more strange.  They later in the opinion stated a very odd way of how a state could comply with PASPA:
Thus, under PASPA, on the one hand, a state may repeal its sports wagering ban, a move that will result in the expenditure of no resources or effort by any official. On the other hand, a state may choose to keep a complete ban on sports gambling, but it is left up to each state to decide how much of a law enforcement priority it wants to make of sports gambling, or what the exact contours of the prohibition will be.
We agree that these are not easy choices. And it is perhaps true (although there is no textual or other support for the idea) that Congress may have suspected that most states would choose to keep an actual prohibition on sports gambling on the books, rather than permit that activity to go on unregulated. But the fact that Congress gave the states a hard or tempting choice does not mean that they were given no choice at all, or that the choices are otherwise unconstitutional. See United States v. Martinez-Salazar, 528 U.S. 304, 315 (2000) (“A hard choice is not the same as no choice.”); see also F.E.R.C., 456 U.S. at 766 (upholding a choice between expending state resources to consider federal standards or abandoning field to federal regulation).
What does this mean?  The court is saying that New Jersey does not run afoul of PASPA if they ban sports betting or they totally deregulate sports betting.  So, in theory, New Jersey could simply allow sports betting with no regulation or oversight whatsoever and the US Government, sports leagues and NCAA couldn't do a thing about it.  That logic is insane and was properly called out in the dissenting opinion.

The opening of the dissent is well written and sums up what I believe the essence of New Jersey's appeal to the US Supreme Court will be:
I agree with my colleagues that the Leagues have standing to challenge New Jersey’s Sports Wagering Law, N.J. Stat. Ann. § 5:12A-2, and that the Professional and Amateur Sports Protection Act (“PASPA”), 28 U.S.C. § 3702, does not violate the principle of “equal sovereignty.” I therefore join parts III and IV.C of the majority’s decision in full. I also agree that, ordinarily, Congress has the authority to regulate gambling pursuant to the Commerce Clause, and thus I join part IV.A of the majority opinion as well. Yet, PASPA is no ordinary federal statute that directly regulates interstate commerce or activities substantially affecting such commerce. Instead, PASPA prohibits states from authorizing sports gambling and thereby directs how states must treat such activity. Indeed, according to my colleagues, PASPA essentially gives the states the choice of allowing totally unregulated betting on sporting events or prohibiting all such gambling. Because this congressional directive violates the principles of federalism as articulated by the Supreme Court in United States v. New York, 505 U.S. 142 (1992), and Printz v. United States, 521 U.S. 898 (1997), I respectfully dissent from that part of the majority’s opinion that upholds PASPA as a constitutional exercise of congressional authority.
This case isn't over and it is my view that the Supreme Court will take it up.  How it turns out is a matter of debate, but my view is that New Jersey should prevail.  It should be noted that a recent statistic indicated that 60% of the rulings from the Third Circuit Court of Appeals are reversed by the Supreme Court.  I think yesterday's ruling overall wasn't too bad at all for New Jersey and those wanting expanded legal sports betting in the USA.

Sunday, May 12, 2013

Other States File Legal Briefs in Support of New Jersey Sports Betting

The briefs regarding the appeal of the recent New Jersey sports betting court ruling are continuing to flow in.  NorthJersey.com reports that the attorney generals in four states, Virginia, West Virginia, Georgia and Kansas, filed amicus briefs in support of New Jersey's efforts to offer sports betting within the state.  The briefs were specific to mention that they did not take a position regarding the sports betting laws under dispute but attacked the US Government position and District Court opinion on sovereignty grounds.

This is an interesting argument.  It appears that this was studied beforehand and coordinated.  Obviously, these states think they have a very good argument on this point and don't want to cloud the issue with details specific to sports betting.

Their point was that by having Congress pick and choose what states can do what, it tramples on the sovereignty of the states.  More than that, the briefs attack the premise of the District Court judge that upheld the sports betting ban (which allow some states to offer sports betting but not others) due to the fact that Congress merely prohibited the states from performing an affirmative action in allowing sports betting.  The four states view this legal position as an error as this court ruling will allow Congress to infringe on state sovereignty by using the tactic of preventing states from performing actions like licensing and permitting as a means of control - an indirect method of federal control over state activity.

The blog puts forward a simple example regarding fishing licenses.  I am sure when the case is heard by the Court of Appeals, there will be better examples ready by the states.  Again, what I find interesting is that the states are very much avoiding the issue of sports betting.  They must feel the issue of federal vs. state sovereignty is quite strong and that the federal side will have difficulty countering.  The Court of Appeals will now more likely take this case under even more consideration as it is not now just a single state (New Jersey) wanting sports betting.  The court will need to decide a larger constitutional issue and if this argument is sufficient, the sports betting ban will have to fall as a natural consequence.

My view is that when this case is ultimately decided by the Supreme Court (the loser here will no doubt appeal), there will be constraints on Congress' actions that will ultimately allow each state to decide for themselves if they desire sports betting.  Nevada's sports betting monopoly days are likely coming to an end.

Wednesday, March 27, 2013

Atlantic City Casinos To Add Fantasy Sports Games For Money

Sticking a finger in the eye of the sports leagues that have won the first legal decision to prevent the State of New Jersey to offer sports betting, New Jersey is allowing casinos to offer daily fantasy sports games as an alternative.  According to the New York Times article, the state’s Division of Gaming Enforcement published regulations establishing standards for casinos to offer fantasy sports tournaments for money.  Even though players will pay money to play and can win cash, New Jersey won't regulate these games as gambling, dovetailing with federal law that distinguishes between fantasy sports and sports gambling.

From a gaming industry perspective, these games are not envisioned to be money makers for the casinos on their own.  They will be used as marketing tools to help attract players that will hopefully stay and play other games, eat at the restaurants, etc.  From New Jersey's perspective, this may open another front in the battle over sports betting, showing the court that what the sports leagues are doing with fantasy sports really isn't all that different than sports betting.  Don't be surprised if the casinos expand the offering to include college sports in addition to professional sports, hoping the NCAA tries to legally stop the activity.  That may be the legal trap being set by New Jersey.

The Times article does quote how this could be good for casinos as people will feel comfortable online with a trusted entity.  The person who said that from a online gambling advocacy group obviously doesn't know anything about fantasy sports.  Over 30 million Americans play fantasy sports now, predominantly online, with large players such as CBS and Yahoo.  They aren't going to switch to some Atlantic casino website because a state government says it is OK.  The federal government back in 2006 said it is OK.

Don't read too much into this development as a great positive for fantasy sports.  Think of this development as another chess move in the battle for sports betting in New Jersey.  If New Jersey wins, that is the big development as that will allow any state to offer sports betting if it desires.





Sunday, March 10, 2013

New Jersey Sports Betting Loses in District Court

Although not totally unexpected, a Federal judge ruled against the State of New Jersey with regard to its challenge to the constitutionality of the Professional and Amateur Sports Protection Act (PASPA).  So, with this ruling, New Jersey can not proceed with implementing sports betting.  As it stands, sports betting is still allowed in just four states:  Nevada, Delaware, Oregon and Montana.

Don't expect New Jersey to quit - an appeal to the US Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit is almost a given.  Whoever loses there will almost certainly appeal to the US Supreme Court.  This is a multi-round fight, but the first round goes to the NCAA and sports leagues.

Read more about this issue here.

Saturday, June 9, 2012

You Can Bet on Sports Where?

In the United States, sports betting is greatly restricted by law.  The two key federal laws are the Professional and Amateur Sports Protection Act (PASPA) and the Wire Act.  This does not mean that sports betting does not occur in the US, it's just that the vast majority is done illegally.  Approximately $2.5 billion is wagered on sports each year in Nevada, but that is a pittance compared to the upwards of $500 billion of sports wagers each year in the US.  There are efforts to expand legal sports wagering in the US at the state level, particularly in New Jersey and California.  You can find posts on those efforts here and here.

Other countries are actually farther ahead of the US in recognizing the fact that sports betting is here, it's big and it's permanent.  A colleague sent me some pictures of a sports wagering outlet in a place about as out of the way from the US as possible - Bishkek, Kyrgyzstan.  Where is that?  About 300 miles northeast of Afghanistan!  Kyrgyzstan is located on the western border of China.  See for yourself...Google Maps / Bishkek









What is interesting is the globality of sports wagering AND the reality that English is truly the world's language.  Not that knowing multiple languages isn't useful, but an English-only speaker by and large could get by in many more places than you might think.


 Add to Technorati Favorites

Saturday, May 26, 2012

California Sports Betting Bill Moves Forward

The California Senate Appropriations Committee passed SB 1390, a bill authorizing sports betting in California, out of committee to the Senate floor for vote.  This is a big step, following on the heels of New Jersey's passing of a sports betting law in January.  As explained by the bill's author, California needs to have a sports betting law on the books so when the anticipated legal battle between New Jersey and the US Department of Justice is fought over the constitutionality of the Professional and Amateur Sports Protection Act (PASPA), California will also have an interest in the outcome.

What has been unexpected has been the bi-partisan support for this measure.  The bill had to pass through both the Governmental Organization and Appropriations Committees, with votes required to move them out (Appropriations actually needed votes to move in and to move out).  All three votes were unanimous, with no abstentions.  Both Republicans and Democrats are in support.  This bill has a real chance of getting through.  To track the bill's progress, you can use this link.

Nevada, currently the state with the de facto monopoly on sports betting, has got to be concerned.  If New Jersey implemented sports betting, yes, that would have some impact on Nevada.  If California implemented sports betting, what does Nevada have left as an attractant to California customers, still a major source of gaming revenue?  There was a previous post that posited an idea to help the northern Nevada casinos deal with increased gaming competition from California.  If sports betting comes to California, all of Nevada may need to consider this.


Add to Technorati Favorites

Wednesday, October 13, 2010

Atlantic City Gambling Revenue Takes Hit

Test Test Test

Bloomberg reports that Atlantic City gambling revenue fell 12% in September 2010 from September 2009 levels. Gambling revenue was $2.8 billion in the first 3 quarters of 2010, which was almost 9% less than the same period in 2009.

The economy is definitely a factor, but the impact of competition must be looked at as the primary factor for reduced gaming revenue. Surrounding states such as Delaware, New York and Pennsylvania have increased their gambling offerings for their local populations. No need to travel to Atlantic City if the gambler can play close to home.

Atlantic City needs to prevail in New Jersey's efforts to allow sports betting to provide the competitive differentiator to bring back this destination. Otherwise, the long term trend for Atlantic City may not look promising.

See previous posts on New Jersey sports betting here, here and here. The posts discuss New Jersey's efforts and surveys with regard to establishing sports betting and overturning PASPA.


Add to Technorati Favorites

Thursday, June 24, 2010

New Jersey Still Looking at Sports Betting

The AP reports that New Jersey wants voters to decide this fall if sports and internet betting should be legalized in the state. Several Democratic legislators are pushing for a ballot initiative for the November ballot. In addition, they have called for a gambling summit that would assemble legislators, gambling industry figures and policy advisers.

The story quotes State Senator Steve Lesniak, " 'There are billions of dollars of gambling money that we're leaving on the table," said Lesniak, who represents a district in northern New Jersey, near where the Meadowlands racetrack wants to offer slot machines to attract new gamblers. That's something Atlantic City has vowed never to let happen.' "

Senator Lesniak has already sued the federal government over the Professional and Amateur Sports Protection Act (PASPA), which effectively bans sports betting in all but four states: Nevada, Oregon, Montana and Delaware. He is challenging PASPA based on constitutional grounds.

In recent years, other states have expanded their gambling offerings, pulling market share from Atlantic City. Senator Lesniak is quoted, " 'Atlantic City is dying,' Lesniak said. 'The Meadowlands is dying. Our racetracks are dying. We have time to get this right and craft a constitutional amendment that will maximize revenues for the state and for our tourist destinations.' " I think he is correct. If New Jersey doesn't do something, Atlantic City gaming will become a shell of what it once was.

Other posts on this topic can be viewed here and here.


Add to Technorati Favorites

Tuesday, May 11, 2010

Delaware's Sports Betting Challenge Fails

The AP reports that Delaware has lost its challenge to the legal ruling that limits them to only offering parlay bets of 3 or more NFL games. Delaware has a grandfather exemption under the 1992 PASPA law, along with Nevada, Oregon and Montana. The exemption allows the grandfathered state to offer only those kind of sports betting options previously offered. Delaware offered a NFL sports lottery back in the 1970s.

Last year, Delaware revived its sports betting offering, but wanted to expand the options to allow single-game sports betting on the NFL as well as other professional sports. The sports leagues objected and filed for an injunction to keep Delaware from expanding their offering. The US 3rd Circuit upheld the leagues' arguments and instituted the injunction on Delaware, which they appealed to the US Supreme Court. The Supreme Court declined to take the case, ending the issue. Delaware will be limited to what they have offered last year.

The State of New Jersey is fighting PASPA on constitutional grounds. Delaware did the same, but did not take the same tack as New Jersey. What Delaware wanted was their ability to expand sports betting without being bound by PASPA, but have all the other non-grandfathered states still be bound by the law - wanting their cake and eating it too. The court saw through this and didn't allow this expansion. If the state wants to operate within PASPA, they need to stay within the stated safe harbors.

New Jersey is fighting to have PASPA declared unconstitutional, which would allow any state to decide for itself what gambling is allowed within state borders. Delaware didn't challenge the entire law, just the portion they didn't like. That approach likely doomed their chances of success. Either they join New Jersey and attack the whole PASPA law, or they need to be satisfied with NFL parlays.


Add to Technorati Favorites

Sunday, December 13, 2009

NBA Commissioner Stern Sees Possibility of Expanded Betting on NBA Games

There has been a crack in the stance in the unified public front of the sports leagues in the US regarding betting on professional games. It should be huge news, but so far there is little significant reverberations of this disclosure. I'm guessing the Tiger Woods story has quite a bit to do with that.

Back to the much more positive sports gambling story. Ian Thomsen's Inside the NBA column leads with an interview with NBA Commissioner David Stern. One of the interview topics was the question of expanded legal sports betting given the Tim Donaghy betting scandal. Donaghy was a NBA referee that was investigated for betting on NBA games as well as perhaps directly influencing the games he was officiating. Another post discussing the Donaghy scandal is here.

In response to the question if sports leagues need to reevaluate their positions with regard to sports betting, Stern gave a very interesting answer. "The betting issues are actually going to become more intense as states in the U.S. and governments in the world decide that the answers to all of their monetary shortfalls are the tax that is gambling."

Saturday, July 25, 2009

MLB, NFL, NBA, NHL and NCAA Sue Delaware to Stop Sports Betting

Yesterday, the major sports leagues (MLB, NFL, NBA, NHL) and the NCAA sued Delaware in an attempt to block the state from offering single-game sports wagers, and keep Delaware limited to offering only parlay sports wagers. The USA Today article has more information on the history and quotes from the various parties as well as a link to the actual pleading.

This blog has previous posts which discuss issues with the Delaware effort, particularly the problems with the government tax structure and the parlay-only offering. Those posts can be found here and here.

The leagues can't stop Delaware from offering parlays, as even the federal law, the Professional and Amateur Sports Protection Act (PASPA), allowed Delaware as one of the four states grandfathered (the others being Nevada, Oregon and Montana) to offer sports betting. Delaware, having offered parlays before, can resume that game whenever they wish. Offering single-game betting is being viewed as an expansion of previously offerings.

From the lawsuit, the leagues claim single-game sports betting in Delaware "would irreparably harm professional and amateur sports by fostering suspicion and skepticism that individual plays and final scores of games may have been influenced by factors other than honest athletic competition." OK...but Nevada's been doing this since like...the 1940s. If any harm would have occurred, wouldn't it have occurred by now?

Besides, the leagues know gambling is an important component to their games' popularity. Why are point spreads published in just about every newspaper in the country, even though sports betting only happens (legally) in Nevada? Why does the NFL publish their injury reports publicly and not just send them confidentially to the various teams? Because they want information in the hands of sports bettors, both legal and illegal.

According to the federal law, the sports leagues have the authority to seek an injunction against operators of sports betting operations - those that aren't grandfathered in. Since Delaware is looking to expand, this might appear to fall outside the grandfathered area. Until now, the leagues have never tried to exercise the law. This is where the situation could get very interesting, and very dangerous for the leagues.

PASPA had some very strong arguments during its deliberation that it is unconstitutional. In essence, the argument was that you can't say 4 states can do something the other 46 can't. Also, since when does the goverment say a private entity has the authority to enforce federal law? States generally have sovereign immunity, so by and large they are immune from being sued unless they allow it. That immunity could be an easy defense. New Jersey has recently challenged the constitutionality of PASPA. A post discussing that case is here, which I recommend reading to learn more of the flaws in this law.

It is in Delaware's interest to keep PASPA in place so that Delaware would have a competitive advantage over neighboring states. It could have sports betting where the others could not. With the New Jersey suit challenging PASPA, Delaware was not likely going to join in as it would not be in its best interest. With the leagues going after Delaware, Delaware will have to fight back. If successful, it will be able to allow single-game sports betting. If unsuccessful, it will only be able to allow parlays.

Here's something very interesting. What if Delaware was too successful in its defense? What if it succeeded in throwing out PASPA? If that happened, every state could offer sports betting if it wanted and Delaware's current advantage would disappear. How Delaware responds to the lawsuit will be telling. They may use the sovereign immunity defense as well as use their constitution saying that a single-game sports bet is basically a one-game parlay. They may not challenge PASPA, or if they do, limit the challenge to the ability of private entities to enforce federal law...not challenge the law in its entirety. Delaware wants the competitive advantage. For that to be maintained, PASPA needs to stay in force.

It will be very interesting to see how this case turns out.


Add to Technorati Favorites